Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Four Different Kinds of 'Christian'

I believe that those who self-identify as Christian can be placed into four different groups. These groups are general: many different kinds of believers can be found in them. Two of these groups believe that Christianity is a kind of universal unattached to history. The other two groups believe that Christianity is a particular that is uniquely historical. These four groups could be called the mystical, moral, cultural and messianic.

Mystical Christians believe that the real essence of what it means to be Christian is found in some kind of mystical union with the divine (God). This mystical union cannot be expressed in words. There is no human language, whether natural or artificial, capable of truthfully conveying what occurs in this mystical union. This view has one essential characteristic. It locates the center of Christianity in a mystical, non-discursive experience.

Moral Christians believe that the real essence of what it means to be a Christian is found in a right moral behavior and thought. This kind of Christian could believe that this moral behavior is found most completely in Christianity, equally in all religions, or just better than most in Christianity. This moral behavior is able to be copied by all, or perhaps only those who are properly enlightened. The only essential characteristic of this view is that the center of Christianity is right morality: both in thought and behavior.

Cultural Christians believe that the real essence of what it means to be a Christian is found in a particular accident of history unique to that individual that associates him with certain beliefs of the time. These need only be moral, mystical or historical beliefs that people of that circumstance associate with Christianity. These circumstances could be racial, political, national or familial. They could be the belief of one's parents, the church one attends, or the moral opinions one espouses. These Christians rarely reflect on their beliefs about the nature of Christianity. When they do, they often think of themselves as being Christians in a lesser sense. The one essential characteristic of this view is that Christianity is an element of culture just like any other cultural element.

Messianic Christians believe that the real essence of what it means to be a Christian is found in the particular history of Jesus of Nazareth understood as the Lord. These Christians disagree with each other over many things, are from many denominations, and include both liberals and conservatives. The one essential characteristic of this view is that the belief that Jesus (of history) is Lord is essential and central to being Christian.

I have been unable to think of a particular view that cannot be subsumed under one of these four. If these are all of the views, then it is only fair to say that I am a Messianic Christian. I should mention a few things though. None of these views entail pluralism, nor do any deny it. It is also possible to believe elements of more than one view. However, it is not possible to believe more than one view.

Labels: , ,

Saturday, March 24, 2007

Understanding "Fundamentalist" Religion

I was reading a post by the Maverick Philosopher and stumbled across a series of statements that I found interesting. Ignoring the various interpretive elements and the truth of both scientific and biblical statements, I focussed on the understanding of "fundamentalist" religion expressed by them. These statements express a misunderstanding of the beliefs of a significant portion of religious believers.

This quote will demonstrate some of what I mean:
Now the Bible story has it that there were these two original human parents, and they came directly into existence by divine agency with God pictured as a Big Man who makes Adam and Eve (Adam out of dust, Eve out of a rib of Adam) in the Big Man's image and likeness.

Now it seems crystal clear to me that this story cannot be taken literally: God is a not a Big Man; image and likeness has nothing to do with physical image and likeness; The human race is not unevolved.
One may wonder whether this kind of literal reading is done and believed by anyone at all, but apart from further comment it could be a statement about how no one reads this text that way to begin with.
Of course, I am not saying that man as spiritual subject can be understood naturalistically. My point is that to read the Bible materialistically is to block out its spiritual message. So perhaps one could say that fundamentalists and their atheist opponents are strange bedfellows in the bed of materialism.
One might be able to say such things if "fundamentalists" of that sort really were a significant portion of the Christian population. More on this later.
But science affirms common descent while fundie religion denies it. Here there is conflict and fundie religion has to give way.
Let's stipulate that if one is a Christian and denies common descent based on one's religious beliefs that one is a fundamentalist. Taking this definition, are the previous quotes really the beliefs of fundamentalists? A simple look would show that this is not true. These fundamentalists do not believe that God is a Big Man, nor do they believe that the Genesis story teaches that we are made in the physical image of God.

Here are some quotes that demonstrate this:
Man in the image of God; what does this mean in practical terms? It cannot refer to bodily, biological form since God is a Spirit and man is earthly. - Creation 4(1):21–29
March 1981

Creationists are often accused of believing that the whole Bible should be taken literally. This is not so! Rather, the key to a correct understanding of any part of the Bible is to ascertain the intention of the author of the portion or book under discussion. - Creation 16(1):38–41 December 1993

When God created man in His own image,7 He purposed that mankind (both man and woman) would resemble God in certain ways, and share certain of the divine prerogatives. - Creation ex nihilo 16(4):42–45 September 1994
These quotes are just a sample of what can be found on the internet. So at least a significant portion of fundamentalists do not read the Bible literally, do not believe in a Big Man and do not believe that man is made in the physical image of God. On its own, this does not show that fundamentalists are believing rationally but it does show that they do not believe in the way that they are commonly depicted. These fundamentalists would agree with the meaning, but not the wording, of the thoughts in this post on the image of God.

One might think that these comments about a set of statements in the comments of a post are a bit much. I mention them because this characterization of fundamentalists is quite common. If one wishes to argue against fundamentalists actual beliefs or characterize them accurately, then I have no problem. This is not one of those times.

Labels: ,